Wednesday, December 23, 2009

Battle of the Luxo-All Stars: Cadillac CTS vs. Lincoln MKS; Is There A ‘Best of Show?’


By Bill Semion

OK, time to get serious. Also, get duded up in two rides that granted, most of us will never see in our driveways. But it’s nice to dream.
            Time to see which of Ford’s and GM’s top luxury nameplates, the 2009 Cadillac CTS, which sports some improvements for 2010, and Lincoln’s new MKS sedan, which also sports improvements for 2010, stand up against each other.
            Turns out, depending on your bias toward either company’s products, and your tastes, both are very similar.
             To start, both are great cars, even handle Michigan’s cratered paved as well as unpaved back roads well, and if you’re shopping in the luxo market, you’d do well to consider either, depending on your nameplate preference. In other words, each vehicle has its plusses.  Gone are the days of the wallowing boats that these nameplates used to be. They are nimble with Euro-coupe qualities in quietness, handling and comfort. Ford and Cadillac have learned well from the likes of BMW, Mercedes and Lexus, and they’re now more than worthy to be mentioned in the same breath.
CTS/MKS War of the Options
            The darling of Bob Lutz when it premiered a few years ago, our version of this V-6 beauty also came with optional all-wheel drive.  However if I owned one, I’d be very tempted to store it in salt season (that’s winter to you non-Michiganders) here in Michigan. I’d hate to start seeing little rust spots on my new Caddy after a few years of driving. And, despite its all-wheel-drive system, which may help towing capacity, the package includes “summer “ performance tires, which means slippery when snowy, unless you purchase a set of winter tires and wheels, another reason to store it in winter.
Look at Me!
            Of the two, the Cadillac is definitely the extrovert.  With sharp, angular bodywork and plunging front end, it’s an eye-catcher. Its nose-heavy look gives it an aggressive stance. Even its middle and last names—performance sedan—evoke power.
            The Lincoln, on the other hand, is more rounded. Instead of angles, curves and sleekness dominate. The hood swoops into a high-arcing door panels and a narrower rear window to finish at a higher trunk area. Use your imagination and you’ll see lines of the past Lincoln Mark series.
            The CTS also came with the optional crystal red paint, a $1,000 option. It’s cool, until you notice the red 2010 Mazda 3 parked next to you with the same paint right down to the gold specks.  But again, if cool red paint is for you and you’ve got an extra grand, why not.
            Tacking on another $1,000 is the Bose surround system with a 40-gigabyte hard drive, enough for, well, lots and lots of songs. It also includes a cool navigation system with 3-D imaging of landmarks. Add another nearly $3,000 for its “luxury collection” of 17-inch wheels, anti theft, leather power seats, heated in front, and a heated windshield washer reservoir.
            The Lincoln sprinkles its options thusly:  19-inch tires, rain-sensing wiper system and keyless push-button start, for $1,100. A hefty $3,000 more gets you its great voice-activated navigation system, which also sports a rear view camera and a built-in hard drive for your songs, books or other data. The MKS also came with $995 adaptive cruise control, which senses cars slowing down in front, and slows you down, too, a great safety device. However, since Ford’s latest Sync update provides turn-by-turn GPS direction assistance, purchasing that option is less of a “need” and more of a “want.” Watch for more Sync updates soon that will make this vehicle even more of a rolling computer.
Driving Impressions—Give and Take
            Step inside the CTS and you feel like you’ve become the car. The twin cockpit, reminiscent of the Corvette, sports butter-soft cream-colored (GM says cocoa) leather seats, wraps around both driver and passenger. The Lincoln’s interior isn’t as swoopy, but it’s just as luxurious, with more straight lines than curves. Seats are great, and Ford’s Sync system is a definite a big plus.
            The Cadillac is quieter than the Lincoln, but because of its sporty feel, back seat space is more cramped for any kids in the mix.  The Lincoln transmitted a lot of front tire whine to the cabin, perhaps because of its tires. The Caddy’s ride is stiffer, which older readers looking for that traditional spongy luxury car ride will not like, but younger drivers will probably enjoy. The Lincoln’s suspension feel is very European, patterned after notables like the BMW. Very refined with great road manners, even on the washboard northern Michigan dirt roads we tested it on near Grayling.  A friend whose lease on his all-wheel-drive Lexus is up took one drive in both the CTS and MKS and said the Lincoln would be his next car. Again, a matter of personal preference.
            However, a female tester preferred the Cadillac’s driving position over the MKS. She did not like the Lincoln’s relatively high front door sills, as well as the narrow back window. It didn’t bother us.  And the Lincoln feels like it would be more at home in snow than the CTS. But based on its overall visual appeal, score one for the CTS.
            Start up the Caddy’s 3.6-liter and it has a definite sporty exhaust tone. Overhead, a double smoke glass sunroof provides almost convertible-like sun without the burn.
            Throttle response is quick in first gear of its six-speed transmission. Principal development of that fuel-saving tranny, by the way, was shared by—guess who?—GM and Ford. So both have very similar transmissions. Both added their tweaks afterward, and both hope to get at least 200,000 miles out of them before anything major breaks.  That is a huge plus, considering how much it costs to rebuild automatics.
            Despite the similarities, the CTS had better acceleration, despite very similar engines. The Cadillac’s 3.6-liter V-6 produces 263 horsepower and 253 pounds of torque. A 304-hp engine is optional. 
            This Lincoln sported a 3.7-liter engine, with nearly identical horsepower. However, for 2010, MKS debuts Ford’s highly touted Eco Boost engine. With the mileage of a V-6, it’s a twin-turbocharged model, producing 355 horsepower, and promising a best-in-class figure of at least 25 mpg. Look for Eco Boost to go in lots of Fords, including a four-cylinder smaller car version. Both vehicles also feature stability control. Based on the new engine promising that increased fuel mileage, chalk one up for the Lincoln.
            At the pump, advantage: Lincoln. We recorded an average 24.1 city, 28.1 highway (EPA rates it at 17/24) with this non-Eco Boost V-6 MKS. The Cadillac registered 18.7 combined (EPA rates it at 17/25). Both require only regular fuel, saving you at the pump.
            Bottom line: both are great vehicles. Both have their plusses, and minuses.  It might come down to your own brand preference that chooses which of these great cars to drive.

At A Glance

Cadillac CTS4
Cost: $37,980MSRP
Price as tested:  (including luxury collection option package featuring options such as machined aluminum wheels and Bose stereo, premium paint, Ultraview glass sunroof, wood trim, $45,100.
Standard equipment includes V-6, six-speed automatic (also available with a stick transmission), traction control, tire sealant kit in place of a spare tire, cruise, XM radio for 13 months, and one year of Onstar.  Price at the dealer is probably lower.

Mileage: EPA rating: 17 city, 25 highway. Auto Focus observed: 18.7 combined.
Estimated insurance cost for six months (based on middle-aged driver with a clear record: $427.64. Source: AAA Michigan).

Likes
·      Great sports car-like feel.
·      Angular, aggressive lines.
·      Beautiful paint, interior and great Bose sound system.

·      All-wheel-drive increases tow capacity, however I’ve not seen a Caddy like this towing anything.
·      Love the almost all-glass roof.

Dislikes
·      Mileage. It could be better, but this model did have all-wheel-drive.
·      Sporty ride may turn off some potential buyers.

Lincoln MKS
Cost: 37,665
Price as tested: (including navigation package and technology package (adaptive headlamps, forward sensing cruise control system and push-button start and interior aluminum trim and 19-inch aluminum wheels), $44,275.
Standard equipment includes capless fueling, Sirius radio, heated and cooled front seats and heated rear seats, steel mini-spare and reverse sensing system. All-wheel drive is available. Price at the dealer is probably lower.

Mileage: EPA rating 17 city, 24 highway. Auto focus observed:  26.1 combined.
Estimated insurance cost for six months (based on middle-aged driver with a clear record: $368.97. Source: AAA Michigan).

Likes
·      Smooth, rounded lines.
·      Great interior integrity, especially on rough roads.
·      Large luggage capacity compared with its rivals.
·      Great THX sound system.
·      More back seat room than a Lexus.
·      Mileage.
·      Adaptive cruise control.

Dislikes
·      The Keyless ignition fob stopped opening the doors at one point. A spare real key is inside the fob.
·      More road/tire noise than you’d expect from a Lincoln.