Sunday, September 27, 2009


Auto Focus: GMC 2009 Sierra Hybrid Pickup

Is the Extra Mileage Worth the Extra Price?



By Bill Semion

The success of GMC’s Sierra hybrid and its Chevy pickup twin stands in the looming shadow of both GM’s money problems and the 2010 Volt, which promises a revolution in auto design: a vehicle running 40 miles on electric power alone before it needs help from its small gas engine.
GM hopes Sierra, that with others it’s also introduced in the Saturn and Chevy lines, it will further enhance its image as a top maker of alternative power vehicles.The big elephant in the room, however, is price. And in the case of the Sierra, it’s awfully big.
After a week behind the wheel of this 1500-series pickup, our mileage, which is what you’d be purchasing a hybrid for, was a mild disappointment. Especially when a neighbor at our Au Sable River house, who drove an all-gasoline-powered Sierra Cab, albeit not the four-door version we tested, reported receiving only a mile per gallon less than our hybrid on our highway test drive.
That leads us to ask, how long do you have to drive this hybrid to make up for the steep $48,000 price tag, before it at least matched driving costs with the gas-only version? And therein lies the problem for this otherwise very capable and well-built vehicle.
Driving Impressions
The truck has admirable manners both on the highway and around town. Roadworthy and very quiet, dashboard options for this 4-by-4 include choosing two-wheel or four-wheel drive high or low with a flick of a switch. Because it’s a hybrid, GM’s owner manual recommends that for maximum mileage, use the vehicle in two-wheel as much as possible, use A/C or heat and electrical accessories including the radio or CD as little as possible, and don’t warm up the engine. Our short-box version came with a 24-gallon fuel tank, and the long box, a 35-gallon tank.
The Sierra’s 300-volt electric drive takes over first from a stop. Turn the key and you’ll hear a slight whir as batteries power up the vehicle first. It can accelerate to 12 mph before calling on the huge, six-liter V8, which produces a hefty 332 horsepower and 367 pounds of torque on its own to help. It’s all pushed to the pavement through a 3.08 rear axle, again promoting better mileage. That’s enough power to, 6,100 pounds for the two-wheel-drive version, and 5,900 pounds because of the extra weight of the 4-wheel-drive mechanicals, The cargo bed can handle 1,500 pounds.
With a bit of practice, however, we were able to gingerly step on the accelerator and SLOWLY achieve up to 25 mph in electric mode only down side streets and flat dirt roads before the gas engine fired up with only the slightest increased pedal pressure.
City driving, of course, is where hybrids usually shine, helped along by stop-and-go conditions and features like the truck’s regenerative braking system, which works during coasting, or as you apply the binders (you’ll soon recognize it turning on by the slight whine as you slow down as it helps to recharge the truck’s battery pack under the rear passenger seats).
Our test vehicle also came with the Z85 handling and trailering suspension, which made for a rougher ride especially over some of Michigan’s bumpy freeways. The gas engine also gains mileage using GM’s variable displacement technology, which it calls Active Fuel Management. Four cylinders on the V8 shut down, turning it into a V4 on downhill runs and relatively flat roads. Transition between four and eight cylinders is seamless, as is the move between the electric and gas motors.
Inside And Out
Our Sierra came standard with power leather-trimmed seats, power windows, convenient rear window defogger, illuminated vanity mirrors, electric seat adjusters and a navigation system with XM radio with real-time traffic info that is free for the first three months.
Also inside are two 12-volt power outlets and power-adjustable pedals. Instruments are easy to read. Dash buttons change driver information, including instant and average fuel economy as well as whether you’re operating on four or eight cylinders at any time. There’s even a tire pressure monitoring system, again to promote optimum mileage, and automatic headlamps. Rear seat head and leg room are ample and seats are comfortable but not dressy.
GM dressed up the exterior with auxiliary turn arrows in the heated mirrors, and a full-size spare, chrome rear bumper and grille, lighted cargo box, and a tailgate that’s much lighter and easier to close than the comparable F-150.
The hard tonneau cover that’s standard on the hybrid Sierra also helps airflow and its mileage numbers. Classy chrome wheels and bulging mock wheel wells give it a classic big truck appearance.
The Bottom Line
As we said, mileage is what you’d invest in a hybrid for. In the city, the vehicle averaged 18.1 miles per gallon, and 19.6 mpg on the highway.
My neighbor, a retired GMC salesman, drove his Sierra 4X4 powered by a 5.3-liter gas engine to Florida last spring, and with a full load said he averaged 18.3 mpg. Which begs the question: While all the technology packed into the hybrid is neat, I could purchase a standard Sierra for thousands less than this hybrid’s $48,000-plus ticket. And even at last summer’s gas prices, it would take me years to make up the difference in fuel costs compared to the hybrid.
Hybrid technology is going to be with us a long time, and it will get better. There will be a need especially in smaller vehicles, because make no mistake, $4 a gallon gas will return.
While the hybrid Sierra has been touted by some as revolutionary, and this first-generation version is a great first step, it will need a bit more refinement (meaning more MPG per dollar invested) until I call it the pickup I’d have in my garage.
At A Glance
GMC Sierra 4WD Hybrid Crew Cab
Cost: $47,675 base price. Price as tested (including touch-screen navigation system, Bose sound system, cargo box tonneau cover, $48,650. Given GM’s financial problems, you can probably expect some deals.
The Sierra hybrid comes loaded. Standard equipment includes power folding, heated mirrors, power driver and passenger seats, auto-dimming rear view mirror, navigation system, exterior fog lamps, stability control to correct trailer sway and more.
Mileage: EPA rating, 20 city and highway. Auto Focus observed, 18.1 city, 19.6 highway.
Estimated insurance cost for six months: $ $390.50 (based on a middle-aged driver with a clear record. Source: AAA Michigan).

Likes
The quiet, mannerly ride for such a big, capable truck.
Ultrasmooth transition between electric and gas operations. There’s only a slight noticeable tick when the gas engine shifts from V8 to V4 mode.
Light tailgate.
Great tow capacity.
The extra mileage.
Dislikes
Not enough extra mileage to justify the price. A few more years of technological improvements in batteries may ultimately make the difference.
Hood shake on the freeway, something that for a vehicle challenging the likes of Ford’s F-150, should not happen.
Quirky dual glove box, including one with a nerdy lift latch.


No comments:

Post a Comment